| Search | Login/Register
   Home » Didital Things » DIY NOS twin 1541A DAC (10 posts, 1 page)
  Print Thread | 1st Post |  
Page 1 of 1 (10 items) Select Pages: 
11-07-2026 Post does not mapped to Knowledge Tree
N-set
Warsaw, Poland
Posts 665
Joined on 01-07-2006

Post #: 1
Post ID: 29848
Reply to: 29848
DIY NOS twin 1541A DAC
I'm separating the thread on my latest baby - a twin 1541A NOS DAC here not to contaminate the thread on the expensive DAC's. The original post:
http://www.goodsoundclub.com/Forums/ShowPost.aspx?PageIndex=2&postID=29828#29828
 Paul S wrote:
Jarek, do I see bypass caps in your PS box? Did you listen without the bypass caps before adding them? 

Paul, there is no bypassing in the PS box but I used extensive bypassing of power supply caps in the signal box. AI has greatly helped me with designing those bypassing strategies and they are consistent with what e.g. Thorsten Loesch and other experienced builders advocates. Having said that, out of 8 supply lines, 7 end up with TentLabs shunts, the only line without them is the digital supply of the 8414 receiver. I did not have the nerve to listen to all bypassing additions and simply assumed a good engineering, accumulated diy experience, and more importantly the high quality shunt, shunting all that cap orgy will work. A guiding light has been this by now famous design:
https://www.mvaudiolabs.com/digital/tda1541a-reference-dac/
Having said that, the only place I indeed tested bypassing was at the 1541A's pins after the shunts. As I wrote earlier, the shunts+ bypasses produced at some point down the I/V resistor value optimization a very particular, highly holographic sound. there was a certain magic to it.  But it was  also "too much" of the holography in a sense that it was leaning towards boominess, like from a tunnel. After some hesitation, I removed the bypasses, the sound actually became a bit more alive although less 3D, and now 1541A's pins are fed directly by the tenlabs, placed only 1cm away. Leter, Lampizator's chief designer, a charming and very friendly guy, told me the boominess is sometimes caused by fresh elcaps, not burned in enough 9mine were off the shelf). 
Another bypass I listened was at the 801A stage output cap. I bypassed Mifles 0.22uF plastics (recommended by Lampizator himself) by Duelund silver foil 0.01uF, I had left from a Tannoy crossover experiments where they did not work. They worked nicely, making the sound more sparkling and adding some detail (both very good for my system).   All those tests were made using Stax Lambda Pro + SRM717 fed by Philips 304MkII and a selection of CD's including Baroque compilation by Alpha with Eva Zaichik and fragments of Guilini's B9.
All that diying wa s abig effort and I want to rest now, so  my plan is:
1) Listen to the DAC for some months, it does produce a very pleasant sound, just not spectacular as I expected. See what happens after 20-50-100h hours.
2) Get a better transport, maybe there is the catch? I'm using Sony 557ESD in the main system with tentalbs clock but after some AI aided searching would like to try CEC TL1X with Lampizator/TentLabs mods of the SPDIF outputs.


Cheers,
Jarek
11-08-2026 Post does not mapped to Knowledge Tree
Paul S
San Diego, California, USA
Posts 2,919
Joined on 10-12-2006

Post #: 2
Post ID: 29851
Reply to: 29848
AI vs.The Notion of Simplicity
Even starting with stock gear one has to break it in (whatever that takes) and let it warm up and stabilize each session (however long that takes). Then, there are cords and cables to consider, along with the quality of connectors and connections, not to mention the AC. At some point, the active consideration of the gear, itself becomes too much for relaxed, attentive listening to Music. As it happens, the only bypass caps I use in my system are for phono stage couplers. Like the Miller effect, or inductive caps, there are almost always "other considerations" in active/reactive/working (vs. static/designed) electrical circuits. Plate curves are a great visual example of this, or a maybe a waterfall plot from a compression driver. The CEC transports sound pretty good if their belts are OK, so they are obviously doing something right, and the Sanyo guts are presumed to be good enough. I listen attentively when clocks come under discussion, but I really don't have a clear idea of how they work from digital input through analog output. Do we need more than one, and how do we keep it to one? My own DAC uses a (tiny) switching PS. Some years ago, a telecommunications engineer (John Rankin) opined at GSC that a properly-done SMPS was the quietest, most reliable way to provide lower voltages in audio gain paths, and I still have the stuff he sent to me so I could prove it to myself. I can easily hold it all (PCBs included) in the palm of one hand. Reactive values are literally forces to be reckoned with, along with "electrical/electronic byproducts" generated by activated parts and clusters of parts. A little Mu metal can go a long way. Another trick I learned was resistors soldered as straight extensions of tube pins, as opposed to right angles, to fit in the chassis. I think we have to somehow clean out the attic before we can really listen to Music. I used to meditate regularly; now it takes a while to get my brain up and running.

Paul S
11-08-2026 Post does not mapped to Knowledge Tree
Paul S
San Diego, California, USA
Posts 2,919
Joined on 10-12-2006

Post #: 3
Post ID: 29852
Reply to: 29851
Hot Mod CEC?
I stuck my head down a Lampizator rabbit hole that featured the CEC TL1 transport. High-end hi-fi cynic that I am, I was amused rather than surprised to find so much Sanyo in a CEC. I was surprised, however, to find that CEC actually effs with and re-arranges the original SPDIF output to achieve the CEC House Sound. No mistaking that for else, I guess...

http://www.lampizator.eu/lampizator/references/CEC/CEC%20TL-1X.html

Paul S
11-08-2026 Post does not mapped to Knowledge Tree
N-set
Warsaw, Poland
Posts 665
Joined on 01-07-2006

Post #: 4
Post ID: 29853
Reply to: 29852
CEC
If I lay my hands on a TL1X, 1st thing to do would be a new SPDIF out via TentLabs clock. 


Cheers,
Jarek
11-15-2026 Post does not mapped to Knowledge Tree
N-set
Warsaw, Poland
Posts 665
Joined on 01-07-2006

Post #: 5
Post ID: 29867
Reply to: 29848
Freaking cables!
I did not believe SPDIF cable could matter...Using a moment of peace and a chance to listen at high volumes, I changed a supermarket-but-solid-looking SPDIF cable to a DIY based on reputable Mogami 2964. Now we are talking! Straight out of the box, the DAC started to come to life, got some live and sparkle that I was missing, the presentation moved from darker/recessed to more neutral, more details appeared by gently, without the glare. I wish I used that cable when voicing the DAC.
To compare DAC's, I briefly went back to my Sony 557ESD audio output for comparison (very good in its own right!) and what earlier sounded more lively, dynamical and impressive, now sounded vulgar and with a digital glare. Twin 1541A sounds definitely more nuanced and..intelligent (for a lack of a better word). If you have any interesting SPDIF cables to compare, I'm interested! First on my list is Mogami 2497. 


Cheers,
Jarek
11-15-2026 Post does not mapped to Knowledge Tree
Paul S
San Diego, California, USA
Posts 2,919
Joined on 10-12-2006

Post #: 6
Post ID: 29869
Reply to: 29867
Caveat Emptor!
Jarek, if you are using a CD transport with a stand-alone DAC you will (obviously...) need 2 runs of IC. While YMMV, my own case establishes that the sum of the links into and out from the DAC may well sound better to you with different cables for each link (SPDIF and 2X RCA, for instance). The old Belken Synapse is definitely one to try from transport to DAC. There is actually a SPDIF thread somewhere on the GSC board. It absolutely matters, unless you insist it does not, in which case, have it your way. Old (NOT new...) Acoustic Revive single conductor might be too much for some systems, as it's fairly raw, but it does pass the extras, for sure. Too bad, but this is another case where one has to pony up, clean and prep connectors, then wait for break-in. Many insist that links to and from a DAC have to be min. 1.5 meters (with all respect to DNM, etc.). AI thinks that's a myth, FWIW. In the end, you buy, you try, you decide.

Best regards,
Paul S
11-15-2026 Post does not mapped to Knowledge Tree
N-set
Warsaw, Poland
Posts 665
Joined on 01-07-2006

Post #: 7
Post ID: 29870
Reply to: 29869
Matters like hell!
Thanks Paul! SPDIF does matter and it wasn't a subtle difference! I'm working constantly with AI as a tool to search and compile reports. Mine, contrary to yours, did find both engineering explanation  and reports on the 1.5m rule.


Cheers,
Jarek
11-22-2026 Post does not mapped to Knowledge Tree
N-set
Warsaw, Poland
Posts 665
Joined on 01-07-2006

Post #: 8
Post ID: 29880
Reply to: 29870
Matters like hell part 2
Amused how stupid SPDIF cables can change the sound, I made another trial - exchanged Mogami 2964 to 2457 cable. Damn me, the sound got bigger, more volume at the same time with increased detailing/articulation, sth that I've been missing. The bass combined with the natural Dannoy bass ability makes we want to lick it for its beauty. It's now more of a window into the musical piece rather than a painting of a window. Guilini's opening of the B9's 3rd movement almost ran me into tears and left me with the feeling we have been discussed here a lot - I stepped into something big that I don't understand but it leaves me in awe.  I'm surprised what a DAC I've cooked! There was a hint of a HF glare but it dissolved or I adapted. Anyway, following the rituals, I'm burning in the cable playing pink noise as  SPDIF.  


Cheers,
Jarek
11-22-2026 Post does not mapped to Knowledge Tree
Paul S
San Diego, California, USA
Posts 2,919
Joined on 10-12-2006

Post #: 9
Post ID: 29881
Reply to: 29880
Building Blocks
Glad to hear this, Jarek, as finding the right S/PDIF is not a given, and it's hard to move on until one gets that link right. You  probably know to be sure everything is optimal, warmed up and settled down before making judgements about HF, per se, as HF problems are endemic to hi-fi, both digital and analog reproduction, and moving too fast on a digital fix can cost when listening to analog, depending on the particular fix, of course. I've found that, if to keep the door open for digital/analog "parity", it is good to check back with analog repro every so often. I've also found that it 's all too easy to lose significant HF that I  do want from a warmed up system by trying to "deal with" HF problems before I tune for the otherwise-best-possible sound, being sure it does not come at the expense of Music. As I told in the first post in my AA Drive 1/iDAT 44 ++ thread, it took me over a decade to get beyond fairly fuzzy digital, since "getting more/better sound" always seemed to result in more discomfort and less Music. I will close with the caution that it is ultimately important that a cable exclude noise, but - unfortunately - this ability is does NOT mean the cable is otherwise "good sonding". Conversely, good sound from a cable does not mean it excludes noise. No fair, but...
I am also very glad your new DIY DAC is helping you to to tune in to more/better Music. If you can discriminate, it means the DAC allows you to do this. On a good day, I forget about the system for immersion in Music that moves me, whether analog or digital.

Best regards,
Paul S
11-22-2026 Post does not mapped to Knowledge Tree
N-set
Warsaw, Poland
Posts 665
Joined on 01-07-2006

Post #: 10
Post ID: 29882
Reply to: 29881
On HF
Good points, Paul, thank you! My listening windows are now short so I did not compare to my analog which is pretty capable, but I did have a thought during the listening that my digital comes now closer to the tape (this should be taken with a huge grain of salt as my only experiences with tape were on audio shows, I don't own a tape machine). But speaking of HF, something interesting is happening: My Tannoy ST-50 supertweeters started to produce interesting effects when listening to the DAC. Before, as I described in the Dannoy therad, I tested them on analog mainly and they worked sort of on/off:either not present or producing unpleasant hard HF (they are well aligned using RTA). I finally turned them backwards, firing at the kitchen behind the speakers with the phase reversed only because my wife liked their looks Smile Now, with the DAC and new SPDIF cables, I re-did the test, setting the x-over point and the sensitivity as high as possible (18kHz, 93dB). Not expecting they would matter or behave differently, to my great surprise, supertweeters instead of 0/1 injecting an annoying HF, started to add some extra air and contour, both good to dilute a bit the sweetness o Dannoys. One reason might be that my DAC is NOS (non-oversampling) so there is no digital filtering. Another, the speaker location - prior to the spdif changes, I made an N-th attempt on the dpols search via the Sumiko methods. I did not get to dpols, not even near, but I did manage to improve the coupling to the room. I started reading the Stirling book and will continue speaker optimization, that I will cover in the dpols thread.  Anyway, the ST50 effects are interesting enough for me to invest in changing their crappy x-over caps to sth better as well as the cable (I used ordinary speaker cable, no spades, just bare multistrand, oxidized like hell)  


Cheers,
Jarek
Page 1 of 1 (10 items) Select Pages: 
Home Page  |  Last 24Hours  | Search  |  SiteMap  | Questions or Problems | Copyright Note
The content of all messages within the Forums Copyright © by authors of the posts